Justin Trudeau blindly endorses the secretive Trans-Pacific Partnership deal, and then attacks Stephen Harper for failing to be transparent “especially in regards to what Canada is conceding”. The post Trudeau’s Endorsement of Harper’s Trans-Pacific Partnership Deal Insulting appeared first on The Canadian Progressive.
Continue readingTag: thomas mulcair
Accidental Deliberations: On campaign reflections
There’s been a flurry of discussion elsewhere about the NDP’s campaign over the past couple of weeks, and I’ll chime in quickly with my own take on how the campaign has developed so far – and what we should hope for as it reaches its conclusion. To start with, I
Continue readingCuriosityCat: Niqab: In defence of Thomas Mulcair
Thomas Mulcair: Man of Principle |
Mr. Mulcair was asked a simple question, loaded with peril, and he answered it very clearly in the last debate on foreign affairs. His answer to the question whether he agreed with the federal court’s decision regarding the right of a woman to cover her face with a niqab was Yes.
CuriosityCat: Niqab: In defence of Thomas Mulcair
Thomas Mulcair: Man of Principle Mr. Mulcair was asked a simple question, loaded with peril, and he answered it very clearly in the last debate on foreign affairs. His answer to the question whether he agreed with the federal court’s decision regarding the right of a woman to cover her
Continue readingFacing Autism in New Brunswick: Wow! Federal NDP Replies to My Inquiry This Morning Re Negotiations to Include ABA for Autism under Medicare
I confess I was surprised to get a same day response this evening from the federal NDP to my question this morning addressed to party leader Thomas Mulcair. The federal NDP committed to continuing the efforts which they have in fact made over the years in Parliament towards creation of
Continue readingFacing Autism in New Brunswick: Wow! Federal NDP Replies to My Inquiry This Morning Re Negotiations to Include ABA for Autism under Medicare
Facing Autism in New Brunswick: Wow! Federal NDP Replies to My Inquiry This Morning Re Negotiations to Include ABA for Autism under Medicare
I confess I was surprised to get a same day response this evening from the federal NDP to my question this morning addressed to party leader Thomas Mulcair. The federal NDP committed to continuing the efforts which they have in fact made over the years in Parliament towards creation of
Continue readingAccidental Deliberations: Tuesday Morning Links
This and that for your Tuesday reading. – Miles Corak writes about the spread of economic inequality in Canada: Companies like ATS epitomize the underlying tide driving jobs and incomes when the computer revolution meets global markets. This tide never went away, even if until a year or so ago
Continue readingAlberta Politics: Russian boots on Syrian ground create new reality for Canadian leaders, whether they discuss it or not
PHOTOS: Russian President Vladimir Putin – creating new realities for Canadian leaders to talk about … or not. Below: The three Canadian debating amigos, Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau, Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper and NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair. As the three principal contenders for the job of running the country
Continue readingThe Sir Robert Bond Papers: White is the new black #nlpoli
2002. Stephen Harper said that his party had a program that would help change the dependence in Atlantic Canada on government spending, a dependence that had led to what he called a “culture of defeatism.” That’s the actual phrase, by the way, “culture of defeatism.” Not a culture of defeat
Continue readingPushed to the Left and Loving It: How Thomas Mulcair Made Clap Trap a Human Right
Pick a debate, any debate, and Thomas Mulcair will find a way to bring up the “fact” that he reduced GHG emissions every year that he was the environment minister in Quebec, and that he was responsible for putting a clean environment as a right into Quebec’s charter. Of course,
Continue readingPushed to the Left and Loving It: How Thomas Mulcair Made Clap Trap a Human Right
Pick a debate, any debate, and Thomas Mulcair will find a way to bring up the “fact” that he reduced GHG emissions every year that he was the environment minister in Quebec, and that he was responsible for putting a clean environment as a right into Quebec’s charter. Of course,
Continue readingPushed to the Left and Loving It: How Thomas Mulcair Made Clap Trap a Human Right
Pick a debate, any debate, and Thomas Mulcair will find a way to bring up the “fact” that he reduced GHG emissions every year that he was the environment minister in Quebec, and that he was responsible for putting a clean environment as a right into Quebec’s charter.
Of course, he will also say that he did not promote the sale of bulk water, despite video evidence. That video got the most re-tweets during last night’s French language leaders debate.
However, that lie is pretty tame, compared to his other whoppers. Let’s compare:
Did GHG Emissions really go Down Under His Stewardship?
In the 2012-13 Quebec government budget report, there is a section Quebec and Climate Change: A Greener Environment. As part of this they produce a graph.
Thomas Mulcair was Quebec Environment minister from 2003 to early 2006, but never drafted a Green Plan until 2004, and never actually acted on anything, favourable to the environment. So his policies (?) had no impact on reducing GHG, but in fact, one in particular, caused a spike.
This was the result of the TransCanada Energy’s combined cycle gas turbine in Becancour, a project he approved in 2004. The generating station was Quebec’s largest source of greenhouse gas emissions in 2007. (Wikipedia)
When Mulcair put his stamp of approval on the project, he had to break the rules established by his own government, since it would not meet the necessary requirements.
According to Mr. Paul-Yannick Laquerre, deputy chief of staff to Environment Minister Thomas Mulcair, the regulations would not apply to the project of Bécancour. Me Laquerre argued that the Régie de l’énergie approved the draft Bécancour on August 23, several months before the adoption of the Regulation …
The Promotion of Sustainable Development
When Yves Séguin resigned as minister of finance in 2005, Thomas Mulcair had hoped to take his place. However, Jean Charest chose someone else. Mulcair went into one of his famous sulks (see political cartoon above), but did a sulk cause Charest to expand Mulcair’s ministry to include sustainable development and parks, which put him in charge of construction projects? Not a promotion, but certainly more power.
This meant that in spite of the announcement that he would finally present a long awaited “Green Plan”, environmentalists were sceptical, and they were right to be, since they soon learned that it was not so much a plan for the environment, as a way of getting around environmental concerns, to aid the construction industry.
In 2012, the Research Quebec Group of Ecologists (RQGE), published a 250 page report for their thirtieth anniversary, in which they detailed their experiences with Thomas Mulcair, during some of their darkest days.
These are some of the things they revealed about his tenure in the Charest government.
1. In 2004, Mulcair announced massive cuts to environmental programs and to groups receiving funding for reseach and public awareness. (p. 220)
2. After meeting with minister Mulcair, whose attitude was less than cordial, environmentalist knew that they would have a different relationship with this government. One that would be more combative in nature. (p146) When the Ministry of Environment became the Ministry of Sustainable Development, and Parks; they noted that “sustainable development” was a new code phrase for skirting environmental protection. RQGE sent out a newsletter warning that with the drastic funding cuts and new policies that put industry first, their very existence was in jeopardy. (p152)
4. … “environmentalists and community networks denounce the forced closure of several citizens groups fighting the environment, consequence of the abolition by the Minister Mulcair of all their funding programs”. This was done so that he could replace their work with “partner companies” [public private partnerships] ” They now knew why Mulcair appointed William Cosgrove, (p157) “Chairman of the World Council water and a champion of private and PPP and asked how Mulcair could “claim to focus his choices and actions towards a sustainable development when appointing a fervent defender of private interests at the head of a provincial organization.” (p166)
5. They also speak of Mulcair’s arrogance: “… he stubbornly refused to meet anyone” and , “The attitude of the Minister Mulcair is unacceptable, even contemptuous, against groups whose survival is threatened by abolishing funding programs ” According to the Director of RQGE Ronald O’Narey, “The minister openly displays his prejudice favourable to the groups that are working directly and measurably in the field and appears biased against groups who issue opinions and comments on everything that contradict his”. (p160)
6. They determined that Mulcair’s Green Plan was “a facade that hid the true intentions of the government” where economic interests would outweigh environmental concerns. (p. 220)
7. When groups began to openly criticize Mulcair they were “… threatened with a SLAPP, and since many were now “completely penniless, since the cuts of Mulcair”, they would not be able to defend themselves.
Mulcair did not disappoint the construction industry though:
Finally the new Ministry of Sustainable Development under Thomas Mulcair, is off to a terrible start. I received an email from the transportation department last week, Informing me that a projected bridge linking Laval and Montreal at 25 Highway, was part of the government’s Plan for sustainable development. This bridge, will sacrifice 2,000 acres of farm land to urban sprawl in Laval, allow 150,000 more cars to enter Montreal each day and funnel off government funds that are desperately needed for public transport. Sustainable development is anything but objective… (Charest’s sinking ship: After only two years in power, the Liberals are going down, Arthur Sandborn, The Montreal Gazette, April 13, 2005)
The bridge that Mulcair approved was dubbed “Mulcair’s Bridge” and Highway 25, was a PPP project. This money was supposed to be earmarked for a commuter service.
Oh, and That Human Rights Thingy
Another claim made by Mulcair is that he entrenched the right to a clean environment into Quebec’s charter of rights and freedoms, but it was a sham. It reads “Every person has a right to live in a healthful environment in which biodiversity is preserved, to the extent and according to the standards provided by law.”
It doesn’t say that laws must protect the right to live in a healthful environment, only that governments must enact their own environmental laws. They could have none at all and still respect the charter.
Is Mulcair a pathological liar? Perhaps. But fortunately, there is a cure for that. Let him retire on October 20. This country cannot afford another anti-environment prime minister.
Continue readingsomecanuckchick dot com: Consider this post a chronicle of Thomas Mulcair’s flip-flop policies…
Consider this post a chronicle of Thomas Mulcair’s flip-flop policies… I could go on… but this is a nice start, eh! In no particular order: [Articles + Videos; In English, or en français.] Shortly after his election to the National Assembly, Thomas Mulcair denounced the political interference of Québec’s powerful
Continue readingsomecanuckchick dot com: These are the types of NDP candidates Thomas Mulcair stands behind…
These are the types of NDP candidates Thomas Mulcair stands behind… Intolerance Rosemont—La Petite-Patrie Alexandre Boulerice says the NDP is against the niqab! [VIDEO, en français!] Mégantic—L’Érable Jean-François Delisle says the NDP should reopen Constitution to deal with the niqab. FYI Jean-François Delisle has backed off his initial statement that
Continue readingAccidental Deliberations: New column day
Here, expanding on this post about the crucial difference between the types of change on offer from the NDP and the Libs. While there wasn’t room for this point in the column, I’ll also note another rather important distinction between the two parties. In the NDP’s case, Prime Minister Tom
Continue readingPushed to the Left and Loving It: The NDP’s Obsession With Justin Trudeau Could be Their Undoing
“I ask you to judge me by the enemies I have made.” – Franklin D Roosevelt Just hours before the Globe and Mail debates on the economy, a story surfaced suggesting that Justin Trudeau was in trouble in Papineau. It started out as “may be” but then quickly changed to
Continue readingPushed to the Left and Loving It: The NDP’s Obsession With Justin Trudeau Could be Their Undoing
“I ask you to judge me by the enemies I have made.” – Franklin D Roosevelt
Just hours before the Globe and Mail debates on the economy, a story surfaced suggesting that Justin Trudeau was in trouble in Papineau. It started out as “may be” but then quickly changed to “is”‘ as the results of a poll were released.
This sampling suggested that Trudeau’s NDP opponent, Anne Legace Dowson (shown above), was 11 points ahead, worrisome if it were true, but it wasn’t. Turns out that it was the NDP who commissioned the poll of 375 people, and that 86% of those they contacted, were NDP supporters.
We can certainly understand the party’s deception, but why would the media go along?
Canada’s polling industry is now worried that this fraudulent survey, that garnered such sensational headlines, will further damage their reputation. It was clearly used to throw Justin Trudeau off his game. His anger did show through, and at times he appeared frantic, that evening, but was still able to get his points across, and the Globe and Mail gave him the win for the best economic vision.
What was supposed to drive voters away from the Liberal Party, and to the NDP, backfired, and they may have lost support from both pollsters and the press, who are less than thrilled that they were dragged down with them.
So Who is This “Star” Candidate?
In 2008, Anne Legace Dowson was introduced to the voting public, by way of a spread published in a Quebec newspaper. In it she compared herself to Barack Obama, and according to the paper, everyone thought of her as “the Oprah of Quebec”.
However, one letter to the editor, questioned this, given that they had never even heard of her “until the media pumped her up”.
I was born and bred in Montreal and consider myself pretty well up to date on who’s who in this city…. but I’ve never heard of this Anne Lagace Dowson until yesterday. That was the day the Montreal Gazette wrote a huge half page story about her nomination.
Today’s supper time local news on ALL the networks had wide coverage of her……it seems like they are trying to make her into the winner before the by-election date has even been set.
She has a radio show on the local CBC station. I think that explains why I’ve never heard of her. CBC english radio usually pulls in between 4 and 8 percent of the english speaking audience….in other words between 92 and 96% of anglo Montrealers NEVER listen to it..!!!!
Legace Dowson was running against Marc Garneau in Westmount, and with the media hype, the prediction was a tight Liberal/NDP race. However, although outspending Garneau, the results were much different than anticipated.
She didn’t compete in 2011, instead focusing on local politics. In 2014 she ran for the seat of commissioner for the English school board. It was an important election, since the very existence of school boards was on the line. The minister of education made it clear, that if there wasn’t more voter interest, he would pull the plug on them.
Legace Dowson led a team of ten, against her opponent’s ten, representing the wards in the school board district. She only managed success in two of the ten, one after a recount, by a handful of votes. She claimed that there was election tampering, though her arguments were weak.
In fact, one of her people actually misrepresented themselves, to obtain voter information, and the police had to be called. It was crazy. The unnecessary drama and feeble campaigning, that garnered just 20% support, hardly makes her a star. At least not in any galaxy I know of.
Given this desperate attempt to make her look better than she is, and more popular than she is; we can only conclude that the NDP are aware of this. If she can’t even come close in a school board election …..
On the bright side. Quebecor knows who she is. That’s something I guess.
Justin Trudeau Forges Tight Alliances
While both the Conservatives and NDP have been relentlessly attacking Trudeau, a strange phenomenon has occurred. Instead of Thomas Mulcair presenting himself as an alternative to Harper, he now appears to be an ally.
Both are committed to balanced budgets, as unrealistic as that is, and both are now committed to the F-35s, simply because Trudeau has promised to scrap them. This puts him with progressives, who also want the procurement stopped, as do many members of the Canadian military, including General Leslie.
Yes, the NDP will argue that Mulcair only wants a better bidding process, but the headlines of Mulcair and Harper opposing Trudeau’s stance, make the two appear as comrades in arms. Not what either of them want, though it will not harm Harper as much as Mulcair.
In trying so hard to discredit the Liberal leader, the NDP have failed to give the voting public a reason to support them. Their platform is weak and financial plan seriously flawed. They produced a nice glossy folder with nothing in it, but gobblygook.
They had hoped to ride the C-51 bus to Election Day, but the wheels fell off. Hope they at least turned off the engine.
Trudeau’s strategy, once thought dangerous, has proven to be brilliant. He has set himself apart from Harper and Mulcair, by claiming that deficits are Ok, F-35s aren’t and high income earners should pay more taxes, so that everyone else can pay less.
He is being judged by the enemies he has made, as Roosevelt opined, and those enemies are looking more like a united front, than competition against each other for the prime minister’s job.
So who’s “not ready” now?
Continue readingPushed to the Left and Loving It: The NDP’s Obsession With Justin Trudeau Could be Their Undoing
“I ask you to judge me by the enemies I have made.” – Franklin D Roosevelt Just hours before the Globe and Mail debates on the economy, a story surfaced suggesting that Justin Trudeau was in trouble in Papineau. It started out as “may be” but then quickly changed to
Continue readingAlberta Politics: What’s next? F-35 boondoggle to land on the deck of a Canadian Mistral carrier?
PHOTOS: The F-35, possibly the worst military aircraft ever made, dollar for dollar or pound for pound, photographed to make it look less like a brick. A hovering version of the same plane. A not-quite-finished Mistral-class helicopter carrier. SANTA FE, N.M. I suppose a hotel in the desert, just down
Continue reading