Peace, order and good government, eh?: Inside the wire

Taliban gun attack, explosions rock Kabul Afghan security forces were battling with Taliban gunmen near the U.S. embassy in Kabul on Tuesday after insurgents launched an unprecedented, multi-pronged attack on the city. That CTV story went up just a few minutes ago and the word "unprecedented" is used at least a couple more times. If you want updates, you might be better to keep an eye on this Guardian piece which is set up to be updated in real time. It’s not clear to me that this is over. This reinforces two things I’ve suggested recently. The first is that Canadian troops aren’t a whole lot safer for being pulled out of Kandahar and reassigned to a training mission. The second is that despite the optimistic assurances of everyone from the top military brass to Pamela Wallin, I think we’re losing. We’re not accomplishing anything by remaining there….

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Not a good start for Topp

NDP leadership candidate Topp says Quebec deserves more seats in House Quebec should join B.C., Alberta and Ontario in getting extra House of Commons seats when Canada’s political map is next redrawn, says New Democratic Party leadership candidate Brian Topp. … He said giving extra seats to Quebec would be a way to recognize its status as a nation within Canada. "I think we need to find an appropriate Canadian compromise," he said… I believe very strongly that, as far as it’s practical, an individual Quebecer’s vote should count every bit as much as mine. Every bit as much, but no more. The reason that giving additional seats to B.C., Alberta and Ontario is up for consideration is that our system is supposed to be based on representation by population. It’s about the math, not about compromising to recognize anyone’s status. The reason for supporting electoral reform — or so I thought — was the recognition that our current system fails badly when it comes to giving equal weight to each individual vote and Topp is now talking about contradicting that effort before we ever get there. If he’s suggesting right out of the gate that we should start compromising…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Apparently propaganda works. Who knew?

Divide between West, Muslim societies ‘irreconcilable’: poll A majority of Canadians believes conflict between Western nations and the Muslim world is "irreconcilable," according to a new national survey that revealed a strong strain of pessimism in the country leading up to Sunday’s 10th anniversary commemorations of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks on the U.S. The survey of 1,500 Canadians, conducted over three days last week for the Montreal-based Association for Canadian Studies, showed 56 per cent of respondents see Western and Muslim societies locked in an unending ideological struggle, while about 33 per cent — just one-third of the population — held out hope that the conflict will eventually be overcome. Are those who voted in favour of the "unending ideological struggle" reacting to Muslims? Or are they reacting to what’s been written about Muslims and about Islam by those whose motives are, shall we say, less than pure? There’s been a well organized and well funded campaign to convince that 56% of the respondents that their fears and concerns are justified. Some of it is motivated by the obvious: fear of the other. Some of it is an effort to sell newspapers and raise ratings. And some of it…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Mostly competent government

You may remember — and if you don’t, this article will remind you — that not too long ago Tony Clement and Rona Ambrose stood on a stage together and announced with great fanfare the formation of Shared Services Canada. This new agency was to drive a complete reorganization of the federal government’s information technology which was to result in greater efficiency and serious savings and would help balance the budget by 2014. Or maybe not. An ambitious project to centralize the federal government’s far-flung data centres will take at least a decade, and require up to $278 million in new spending, an internal report concludes. … … the internal report, obtained by The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act, suggests any projected savings are long-term, with consolidation complete only in about 2024. "Data centre transition of service delivery and transformation of the environment is not a low risk undertaking," warns the document, dated April 25, and stamped "protected, private and confidential." Dated April 25. So Clement and Ambrose had this report in hand and knew its contents when they did their dog and pony show and assured us that we’d see savings from this in three years…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Can I get a cite please, Mr. Goodale?

Someone on Twitter just pointed to this statement on Liberal MP Ralph Goodale’s website and I’d like to see some back up for this: Both the Conservatives and the NDP claim that Canadians would be better off with only two political parties (them, of course) dominating our system of governance – one on the right and one on the left, just like the Americans. … A Conservative/NDP push for ideological polarization in Canada is self-serving and wrong. In the context of all the recent talk of merger, I’ve certainly seen NDP members — most notably Ed Broadbent — encourage any Liberals who want to see a single party on the left to leave the LPC and come join the NDP. But has anyone who’s seriously in a position to speak for the NDP actually promoted the idea that we need a two party system? I’d really like to know so I can yell at them. Among other reasons, I was of the opinion that the NDP favoured some form of proportional representation and that would be completely unnecessary with a two party system. That would mean the NDP is talking out of two sides of its mouth on an issue…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Just say no to "extraordinary anti-terror powers"

It was reported yesterday that the Harper Government™ (apparently they really do want to be called that) intends to bring back a couple of "extraordinary anti-terror powers for police": preventative detention and compulsory (and secret) testimony. These are measures which were part of the original Canadian response to 9/11 but were allowed to sunset in 2007 because the Conservatives couldn’t get enough opposition support to keep them in force. The Ottawa Citizen has published an unsigned editorial opposing the measures and makes the obvious observation: The actions of police at the G20 summit in Toronto last year, when more than 900 people were arrested during a single weekend, showed that even in a well-governed and free country such as Canada, we can never simply trust that authorities will use extraordinary powers appropriately. In the last few years, police forces have not demonstrated that Canadians should entrust them with more power; if anything, they have eroded confidence in their judgment. If anything, that’s understated. In the last few years the media have been full of stories involving law enforcement and intelligence agents who have abused the authority they already have and sometimes demonstrated gross incompetence in the process. Mostly, they investigate…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Noise

Apparently Gary Doer, our ambassador to the United States, doesn’t have a lot of respect for people who disagree with him on whether or not the proposed Keystone XL pipeline should be approved. Canada’s ambassador to the U.S. Gary Doer said Tuesday he is confident the Obama administration will approve the controversial Keystone XL oilsands pipeline if it is guided by facts about the project’s safety and environmental impacts, and not the "noise" generated by opponents who protested for two weeks outside the White House. You’d think someone who is now a professional diplomat might be just a bit more circumspect about the way he refers to people who oppose the pipeline and their reasons for doing so. His casual dismissal might be seen as just plain insulting. Personally I’m not too thrilled that someone who is supposed to represent me on the international stage has so little time for some of the people who oppose the project. OTTAWA (September 7, 2011) – Nine distinguished recipients of the Nobel Peace Prize have written to President Obama, urging him to reject the proposed Keystone XL tar sands oil pipeline, saying his decision offers "a critical moment" to make good on his…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: The issue that just keeps hanging on

While I’m sure our Conservative government would like to consider the matter of the treatment of Afghan detainees closed, it’s in the news again. Both the CBC and the Globe and Mail are reporting that NATO forces have halted the transfer of detainees to a number of Afghan prisons in advance of a report to be released shortly by the UN. According to Paul Koring at the Globe, the report will detail "brutal and systemic torture in Afghan prisons." None of the prisons involved in today’s news report are in Kandahar, where Canadian troops served until recently, but they do include facilities run by Afghan’s NDS which ran facilities that accepted prisoners from Canadian troops. As for Kandahar itself, transfers to Afghan authorities there were already halted in July. With a majority government, certainly the Conservatives are an even better position to stifle any attempt to re-open an official investigation here. But depending on just what’s in that UN report, there could at least be a fresh media storm on the horizon….

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Why not just have the Americans write our legislation for us?

Michael Geist in today’s Toronto Star: Secret U.S. government cables show a stunning willingness by senior Canadian officials to appease American demands for a U.S.-style copyright law here. The documents describe Canadian officials as encouraging American lobbying efforts. They also cite cabinet minister Maxime Bernier raising the possibility of showing U.S. officials a draft bill before tabling it in Parliament. The cables, from the U.S. Embassy in Ottawa, even have a policy director for then industry minister Tony Clement suggesting it might help U.S. demands for a tough copyright law if Canada were placed among the worst offenders on an international piracy watch list. Days later, the U.S. placed Canada alongside China and Russia on the list. Did Maxime Bernier not see a problem with allowing a foreign government to see and approve legislation before the people he’s elected to represent get to see it? Did Tony Clement and his policy director care whether there was any objective reason to have Canada placed on that "offenders" list? Did they not see a problem with encouraging a foreign government to condemn their own citizens to serve someone else’s agenda? Those are rhetorical questions, in case that’s not obvious. It’s becoming clearer…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Gee, how did that happen?

This whole Carol Goar column is worth a read and I may just come back to it when I have more time, but when I read this one line, well, let’s just say it’s a good thing I wasn’t eating or drinking at the time or I’d probably have to go out and buy a new keyboard. our employment insurance account has a $10.4 billion shortfall As I’ve pointed out before, that would be because Liberal and Conservative governments combined to make $55 billion disappear, leaving a program that was never intended to be a source of general revenue with a large shortfall when it’s most needed. And to add insult to injury, with the second half of the double dip on the horizon and the government itself adding to the number of jobless, the current group of con artists — supposedly in an effort at modernization — is busy hacking away at the EI program’s ability to help the newly unemployed apply for benefits. Is it too early in the day to have a drink?…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Taking care of business

The Financial Post is pleased to report that Suncor Energy Inc., along with other oil companies, is preparing to return to the Libyan oil fields. After six months of intense fighting that shut down oil-production facilities and forced massive evacuations of expatriate oil workers, Libya’s future as a place to do business brightened dramatically as leaders of the Libyan uprising met with world powers in Paris to map out the country’s rebuilding and Canada lifted unilateral economic sanctions imposed last February. My emphasis. And that, after all, is what this has mainly been about, isn’t it? It wasn’t a matter of ensuring that Libyans could control their own destiny. It was about ensuring that the right Libyans ended up in control of the oil fields — the Libyans who were already on good terms with NATO countries, who were already in favour of privatizing Libya’s oil and who would be agreeable to giving easy access to the countries who helped them take control. Until recently I’d been thinking of NATO as an organization desperately seeking justification for its own existence since the original threat it was to protect against had faded. Now I think of NATO as just one more…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Simple Answers to Simple Questions

In a Toronto Star article about upcoming discussions between our government and the Americans concerning border security, Canadian Chamber of Commerce President Perrin Beatty puts the question: We have to ask ourselves: What is the reason for the government presence along the 49th parallel at this stage in the 21st century? I’m going to take the liberty of assuming that Beatty isn’t suggesting there be no government presence at all. He wants to know why there is so much more "government" involved in moving across the Canada-US border than previously. And the simple answer is: a concerted effort to grossly exaggerate a threat that actually kills fewer people every year than lightening strikes. Or as Glenn Greenwald referred to it yesterday: The decade’s biggest scam. There’s much more at that link but the motivation for the scam can be boiled down to pretty simple terms too: power, profit and the protection of power and profit. Beatty seems to understand the problem when he says: We’re doing things to ourselves that Al Qaeda never could have dreamt to have done to us directly… But he also seems quite content to have us hurry up and continue doing it to ourselves —…

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: Friday night

I didn’t realize until I had all three of these videos together that they all source back to an outfit called Music Fog. If they’re going to keep providing live performances with good production values I’ll have to pay more attention. According to the bio on his website, David Jacobs-Strain’s first love was the Delta blues. As soon as I heard the 12 string acoustic slide I thought it might get interesting. Nice harp, too. This is Hurricane Railroad….

Continue reading

Peace, order and good government, eh?: And this is where we juxtapose

Yesterday in the Guardian (with my emphasis): Nato will continue to deploy strike aircraft, spy planes and unmanned drones over Libya but will not put any troops on the ground to help the transitional council maintain law and order, alliance officials made clear on Wednesday. I’m sure that means just as much as the previous commitment not to put boots on the ground at all. Yesterday on CNN International: Special forces troops from Britain, France, Jordan and Qatar on the ground in Libya have stepped up operations in Tripoli and other cities in recent days to help rebel forces as they conducted their final advance on the Gadhafi regime, a NATO official confirmed to CNN Wednesday. … Qatari and French forces also have provided some armaments, the official said. The NATO spokesperson in the first article says that helping the new Libyan government to keep order is a perfect job for the UN. Knowing full well that the UN has few options in that regard that don’t involve NATO countries, he goes on to state that NATO would be pleased to help the UN if asked. I’m sure they would. H/t to Toedancer for the CNN article….

Continue reading