So, the Catholic Church thinks it has something relevant to say about physician assisted death? After reading through the Bishops’ letter to Alberta’s Premier Notley, it’s an amazing piece of hypocritical nonsense. The Catholic Church is committed to protecting and caring for the most vulnerable people in our society; this
Continue readingTag: ethics
The Cracked Crystal Ball II: Speaking Of Hypocrisy
After reading through the Bishops’ letter to Alberta’s Premier Notley, it’s an amazing piece of hypocritical nonsense.
The Catholic Church is committed to protecting and caring for the most vulnerable people in our society; this includes, of course, those who suffer and dying Albertans. Catholic healthcare in Canada, and in our province, has given witness to this from our earliest history.
Except for those Albertans who happen to be LGBT, apparently.
We want to be clear that, from a Catholic perspective, the intentional, willful act of killing oneself or another human being is morally wrong. Therefore, no Catholic – including elected officials and healthcare professionals – may advocate for, or participate in any way, whether by act or omission, in the intentional killing of another human being either by assisted suicide or euthanasia.
First, if laws and regulations governing the legalized acceptance of assisted suicide and/or euthanasia are to be adopted, then we must accept that they will, in principle and practice, affect all Albertans. Therefore, we ask that your government undertake a consultation process open to any and all who wish to speak to the issue.
Well, since the laws involved are predominantly Federal jurisdiction, I don’t see where Alberta’s government has much to say about the matter. Outside of Quebec, no province seems to have significant plans on this matter, and are waiting for June when the Federal Government has to have passed new legislation.
Second, we are gravely concerned that the legalization of assisted suicide and/or euthanasia will place certain members of our common home at serious risk. In jurisdictions that have already adopted laws permitting euthanasia and assisted suicide, what are purported to be “safeguards” against abuse of the law have proven in practice to be no safeguards at all. The measure of a just and ethical society is the extent to which it cares for – and protects – its most vulnerable members.
Really? What examples would you cite? Oh, I know, you’d probably dredge up the idiotic crap that LieSite has been spouting ever since a couple of countries in Europe changed their laws. Besides being largely hysterical reporting, LieSite has an extreme agenda to start with.
However, then the Bishops delve into the bag of “pro-life” lies on the subject:
These are our mothers and our fathers; they built our homes and our province. They are not a burden, and they must not be led to feel that way through our individual and collective indifference.
Yeah. Sure. People are not going to ask the doctor to kill their parents off. However, these Bishops might want to spend some time in a palliative care ward filled with people dying slow, agonizing deaths at the hands of disease before they pull such emotional arguments out of their cassocks. (I’ll come back to this in a moment)
Even today, many of these people often experience unjust discrimination and the sting of stigma from their family, friends, colleagues and society. In other jurisdictions, this group has in particular been disproportionately represented in cases of assisted suicide and euthanasia.
Coming from a Church which denies the validity of transgender identities, and calls homosexuality “a sin”, this position is almost laughable. I wonder if it has occurred to them just how much their teachings contribute to an attempted suicide rate among transgender people that runs upwards of 40%?
They save the money shot for the very end, and delve into the messy pot of issues called “Conscience Rights”:
Third, other provincial jurisdictions in Canada have proposed regulations that undermine the conscience rights of physicians and other healthcare workers. This must not be allowed to happen here. Physicians, other medical professionals, and our institutions have to be allowed the freedom that is theirs by right to exercise their conscience, not only to accord with our Charter of Rights and Freedoms, but also as a matter of good medical practice.
Conscience rights is nothing more than the latest pro-life gambit to create a hierarchy of rights that places an individual’s religious conscience at the top of the heap.
Let me be clear. Assisted death is a very prickly, emotional subject. Yes, there are religious and conscience issues involved. Lots of religions teach a particular ethic about life, and even without that stricture in someone’s life, many would be rightly uncomfortable with such decisions.
However, it is far too simplistic to simply say “it’s a sin, therefore it should be banned”. One only has to spend time in and around palliative care wards watching people in their last days and weeks to know that exiting this world is not always a peaceful, quiet experience. Terminal illness can be painful and brutal, robbing people of autonomy, dignity and peace. It’s a terrifying, painful experience for some, and one that is not always remediated well by painkillers.
This is a matter of patient rights to self-determination and caregiver ethics coming into some degree of conflict. Most ethics codes reflect the right of the patient to informed consent, and to refuse treatment. We have to remember that the person at the center of this discussion is the patient, not the caregiver and definitely not the caregiver’s church. Even the CMA’s statement on this subject is fairly clear – a doctor does not have to participate in the actual act, but they are not allowed to be an obstacle to it either.
Where the religious notion of “conscience rights” becomes problematic is that they have begun to extend it to include being “complicit in the deed”, usually as a means to try and sidestep the duty to refer to a caregiver who is willing and capable. We’ve seen this played with the abortion game, and I have no doubt that’s what the Bishops would advocate here as well. This is where we tip the scales and pass from supporting the individual’s conscience rights and it becomes a matter of imposing one’s conscience objections on the patient. Considering the patient’s state and vulnerability, this is not only problematic, it is arguably exploitative as it places the patient in a jeopardy situation where they then would have to find the means to access a willing caregiver. (Which, if you are hospitalized or bedridden, can be damned difficult)
Alberta’s Bishops would do us all a favour if they took a more nuanced approach to matters rather than simply trying to railroad the rest of the province with centuries old dogma.
The Cracked Crystal Ball II: Speaking Of Hypocrisy
So, the Catholic Church thinks it has something relevant to say about physician assisted death? After reading through the Bishops’ letter to Alberta’s Premier Notley, it’s an amazing piece of hypocritical nonsense. The Catholic Church is comm…
Continue readingScripturient: Sloppy Reporting and Secret Agendas
One really doesn’t actually expect sterling journalism, good, investigative reporting or excellent editing from a community newspaper, but we do expect factual accuracy. And we expect reporters and editors to do at least the basics of their jobs….
Continue readingIn-Sights: Mythomania
Merv Adey (BCVeritas.com): “The proper role of political media is to unspin the various prevarications and lies governments like to foist on us.”B.C. Premier Christy Clark still trying…, CBC News, February 6, 2016:Clark campaigned in 2013 on B.C. bei…
Continue readingIn-Sights: Difficulties mount for BC Liberal partner
French list Malaysian PM Najib Razak in bribery case file, The Australian, February 6, 2016Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak is facing a new front in a multi-billion-dollar corruption scandal bedevilling his administration, with French investigators…
Continue readingScripturient: More secrecy, more witch hunt, less accountability
“Those who gain a good reputation should be commended.” So starts the Lay of Guigemar, by Marie de France. It seems like mere commonsense, doesn’t it? We should laud those who achieve good things, who accomplish feats and goals, recognize with th…
Continue readingDead Wild Roses: The American Anti-Choice Movie Bullshiters Indicted – About Frackn’ Time
Finally. A Houston grand jury investigating undercover footage of Planned Parenthood found no wrongdoing Monday by the abortion provider, and instead indicted anti-abortion activists involved in making the videos that targeted the handling of fetal tissue in clinics and provoked outrage among Republican leaders nationwide. This is what happens when your platform is based […]
Continue readingScripturient: Monday’s Limited Choices
Here are the choices Collingwood Council faces, Monday night, when dealing with the unethical, immoral and probably illegal actions of the two renegade members of council. You’ll recall that these two sent out an unauthorized, and what I and othe…
Continue readingScripturient: More Bad Ideas
Arguably the worst decision ever made by a Collingwood Council in my memory was to rescind the heritage permits from the Admiral Collingwood development, back in 2007. The results of that motion – moved by former Mayor Carrier and seconded by C…
Continue readingScripturient: The Litmus Test
Two renegade members of council broke the town’s Code of Conduct by sending out an unauthorized media release to defend their own, personal positions – but presented them as “town” positions. You already know that reprehensible …
Continue readingScripturient: That WTF Moment
WTF. Those three letters crudely but superbly sum up the two-page response made to the two members of council who recently sent out an inappropriate media release, pretending it came from the town. The letter was written by Remo Niceforo, President of …
Continue readingIn-Sights: A reader comments
I’ve been reporting information taken from annual and quarterly reports of BC Hydro. There are important economic issues and billions of dollars at stake and the people who benefit from the way BC Hydro operates are many, some of them influential. Corp…
Continue readingScripturient: The Blackened Nose
There’s a famous Zen tale that I was reminded of as I was reading the media release about the Collingwood Airport this week. It somehow seemed remarkably fitting. It’s about the folly of selfishness, of thinking yours is the only way forwar…
Continue readingScripturient: Council’s First Year Reviewed
As we come close to the end of 2015, it’s time to take stock of what your Collingwood Council has accomplished in its first year in office. Let me start by saying it’s up to you to decide whether we have the best people at the table to re…
Continue readingIn-Sights: Deceit as government policy
Writing in The Tyee, Damien Gillis provides the best analysis I’ve seen of Christy Clark’s LNG fantasies. Read it and share it. Three Fibs Premier Clark Uses to Sell LNG DreamSorry, it’s not clean. It won’t pay off. It’s not popular. Here’s why.Fib #1:…
Continue readingIn-Sights: It’s a start
B.C. Liberal party executive director resigns, facing criminal charges in Ontario, CBC News, December 17, 2015:Laura Miller charged with breach of trust, mischief, and misuse of a computer system to commit mischief…Questions we must ask:Why was a per…
Continue readingArt Threat: Curating the North: Documentary Screening Ethics and Inuit Representation in (Festival) Cinema
Documentary festivals are certainly not immune to scandal and controversy, and this year’s RIDM, which took place in Montreal in November 2015, was no exception. Following on the heels of the festival’s public screenings of Dominic Gagnon’s film Of the North, Inuit artists like Tanya Tagaq and Alethea Arnaquq-Baril took to social media to express […]
Continue readingScripturient: Our ruined reputation
Collingwood’s reputation is in tatters. But you wouldn’t know that from the local media coverage. A story in the Stayner Sun this week illustrates just how bad it has become. It should have been front page in this week’s Connection: C…
Continue readingScripturient: Screw the Taxpayer
Sitting down? Good. You might want a drink, too. A strong one. Ready? Get a grip on your chair. Here goes: Collingwood is looking at a 3.9% tax hike for 2016. And that’s just its own portion. Let me help you up. No, that isn’t wrong. ItR…
Continue reading