On that whole Nycole Turmel thing … – Progressive Bloggers // Blogues progressistes

While we’re on the subject of journalistic ethics, let me just cite pogge and thwap. They’ve already said it better than I can.

From pogge:

Every year or two I find a reason to point to Declan’s post on the Media Failure Two-Step. (And actually I could find a reason much more often than that.) To review, the Two-Step looks like this:

Step 1) Cause something (bad) to happen through your reporting.

Step 2) Report on this (bad) thing from the perspective of an innocent bystander.

And then you just repeat indefinitely.

Our latest example? With the Globe and Mail leading the charge, since yesterday many in the media have been having a great old time implying that a Quebec politician who has previously been involved with the BQ is somehow unfit for her position as an interim leader for the NDP. That in turn would imply that about half the voters of Quebec are illegitimate participants in the democratic process until they somehow redeem themselves to the satisfaction of the Globe’s editorial board. And in case it isn’t obvious, deserting the BQ in droves to vote for the NDP isn’t sufficient for the purpose.

And from thwap:

Whether the NDP has tossed a rope down to allow the Liberal Party of Canada to clamber back up out of the grave is something I’m not prepared to speculate upon, nor is it something I’m inclined to speculate upon.

I’ll let the voters decide. And I can’t predict that.

It does show that the Liberals are looking to knock the NDP off from its perch as the second party in Canada. For the issues of economic and foreign policy, I hope they fail. I hope, for reasons of foreign and economic policy, that the NDP hews closer to the principles of former BQ voters in Quebec. Because given the failure of mainstream (read: harpercon and Liberal) economic and foreign policies, the NDP might just find that adhering to Quebeckers values will resonate with more and more people in English Canada.

It’s just this sort of stupidity from the Village that’s brought us to the point we’re at now. I’m not carrying water for anyone, but if the NDP chooses not to play this game by these rules, then I say good on them. The reaction from the political and media establishment will, of course, be furious — and predictable. That’s up to them. Whether we allow it to matter is up to us.

Related posts: